Critiques/2010-03-21
From PCSAR
(→misc) |
(→Suggestions by functional area) |
||
Line 63: | Line 63: | ||
=== first notification / tasking === | === first notification / tasking === | ||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug2}} | ||
* {{sug|2}} clarify purpose of task | * {{sug|2}} clarify purpose of task | ||
** not | ** not | ||
+ | |||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug3}} | ||
* {{sug|3}} on-call person to have call-out list on person - program cell phone | * {{sug|3}} on-call person to have call-out list on person - program cell phone | ||
** already done | ** already done | ||
Line 74: | Line 77: | ||
=== call-out === | === call-out === | ||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug7}} | ||
* {{sug|7}} wait before rushing to maximize prep time | * {{sug|7}} wait before rushing to maximize prep time | ||
** we're stood down often | ** we're stood down often | ||
** not | ** not | ||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug8}} | ||
* {{sug|8}} be prepared for call out at any time | * {{sug|8}} be prepared for call out at any time | ||
** done | ** done | ||
{{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug9}} | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug9}} | ||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug10}} | ||
* {{sug|10}} + had comms between different training sites | * {{sug|10}} + had comms between different training sites | ||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug11}} | ||
* {{sug|11}} stage people at the scene | * {{sug|11}} stage people at the scene | ||
ack | ack | ||
Line 97: | Line 104: | ||
{{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug18}} | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug18}} | ||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug19}} | ||
* {{sug|19}} level of detail of patient status | * {{sug|19}} level of detail of patient status | ||
** privacy | ** privacy | ||
Line 117: | Line 125: | ||
{{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug27}} | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug27}} | ||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug28}} | ||
* {{sug|28}} + teams deployed quickly | * {{sug|28}} + teams deployed quickly | ||
** teams got out quickly when they were tasked. | ** teams got out quickly when they were tasked. | ||
Line 133: | Line 142: | ||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug38}} | ||
* {{Sug|38}} reinterpretation of assignment. when does a clue become a change of assignment? Could you change assigned search type without confirmation from command. | * {{Sug|38}} reinterpretation of assignment. when does a clue become a change of assignment? Could you change assigned search type without confirmation from command. | ||
** comes with experience | ** comes with experience | ||
Line 142: | Line 152: | ||
=== access/return from segment === | === access/return from segment === | ||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug42}} | ||
* {{sug|42}} never split team returning from field | * {{sug|42}} never split team returning from field | ||
** training exercise artifact | ** training exercise artifact | ||
Line 164: | Line 175: | ||
=== operations === | === operations === | ||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug51}} | ||
* {{sug|51}} balancing priorities with multiple subjects | * {{sug|51}} balancing priorities with multiple subjects | ||
** handled appropriate | ** handled appropriate | ||
Line 169: | Line 181: | ||
=== media === | === media === | ||
=== family === | === family === | ||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug52}} | ||
* {{sug|52}} + family liaison | * {{sug|52}} + family liaison | ||
=== post ops === | === post ops === | ||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug53}} | ||
* {{sug|53}} Nobody should leave until everything is packed up to go. Don't leave until released. | * {{sug|53}} Nobody should leave until everything is packed up to go. Don't leave until released. | ||
** same as before | ** same as before | ||
Line 178: | Line 192: | ||
(e.g., how this critique was organized, mock search goals, exercise techniques) | (e.g., how this critique was organized, mock search goals, exercise techniques) | ||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug54}} | ||
* {{sug|54}} more scenarios | * {{sug|54}} more scenarios | ||
** on the mock | ** on the mock | ||
Line 184: | Line 199: | ||
=== misc === | === misc === | ||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug55}} | ||
* {{sug|55}} use the best equipment -> index criteria | * {{sug|55}} use the best equipment -> index criteria | ||
** not understood | ** not understood | ||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug56}} | ||
* {{sug|56}} get stuff ready sooner, incl. vehicle | * {{sug|56}} get stuff ready sooner, incl. vehicle | ||
** covered earlier | ** covered earlier | ||
Line 193: | Line 210: | ||
{{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug59}} | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug59}} | ||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug60}} | ||
* {{sug|60}} + accountability at hill | * {{sug|60}} + accountability at hill | ||
+ | {{quote-page|{{PAGENAME}}/Sug61}} | ||
* {{sug|61}} Had radio reception, but no phone reception. use mountain safety office. | * {{sug|61}} Had radio reception, but no phone reception. use mountain safety office. | ||
** Knowing in advance where good facilities are at CMR - e.g. command post. | ** Knowing in advance where good facilities are at CMR - e.g. command post. | ||
** handled | ** handled |
Revision as of 07:45, 20 September 2012
Suggestions coming from the March 21, 2010 critique regarding the March 20 mock search and the March 7 avalanche response.
Pincher Creek SAR routinely performs a critique after a Search and Rescue incident in order to learn what should be done differently or the same in the next similar incident. Critiques are not about criticism but rather about learning. They are normally chaired by a Search Manager that was not involved in the incident. The suggestions that are brought forward through the critique process are presented in this report.
Committee / Organization
The suggestions are being passed on to the indicated organizations/committees for their consideration. We recognize that not all suggestions may be appropriate, and some may already have been implemented.
PCSAR Board
Mandate Relevant to Incidents:
- Overall ability of PCSAR to accomplish its mission.
- Organizational policies
- Relationships with Tasking Agencies and Fellow Responding Organizations.
- Financing, budget
suggestions identified:
PCSAR Preplan Committee
Mandate Relevant to Incidents:
- Expertise in search and rescue.
- Standard Operating Procedures for incidents.
- Post incident critique, review and follow-up.
suggestions identified:
PCSAR Equipment Committee
Mandate Relevant to Incidents:
- Obtaining and keeping equipment ready.
suggestions identified:
PCSAR Call-Out Committee
Mandate Relevant to Incidents:
- Respond to First Call from Tasking Agency
- Contacting members during an incident.
suggestions identified:
PCSAR Membership Committee
Mandate Relevant to Incidents:
- Recruiting members.
- Tracking members contact information, skills and equipment.
suggestions identified:
PCSAR Training Committee
Mandate Relevant to Incidents:
- Training members.
suggestions identified:
Tasking Agency
Mandate Relevant to Incidents:
- Overall legal responsibility for incident.
suggestions identified:
Fellow Responding Organizations
Mandate Relevant to Incidents:
- Response to incident in accordance with their individual mandate and ability.
suggestions identified:
Suggestions by functional area
mandate
|
first notification / tasking
|
-
Suggestion #2:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
clarify purpose of task
- not
|
-
Suggestion #3:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
on-call person to have call-out list on person - program cell phone
- already done
|
-
Suggestion #5:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
+ immediate notification by RCMP, ramp up resources
- ack
Merge from Critiques/2010-08-24/Sug14
|
call-out
|
-
Suggestion #7:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
wait before rushing to maximize prep time
- we're stood down often
- not
|
-
Suggestion #8:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
be prepared for call out at any time
- done
|
|
-
Suggestion #10:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
+ had comms between different training sites
|
-
Suggestion #11:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
stage people at the scene
ack
investigation
-
Suggestion #12:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
+ feed into the search manager info from Family, without taking time out from the search
communications
|
focus on strengths of certain people as command post radio operator
|
|
|
2012-09-18 preplan
|
|
|
-
Suggestion #19:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
level of detail of patient status
- privacy
- First priority was information. Not guarding communications.
- not
-
Suggestion #20:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
+ had multiple forms of communication
|
|
|
resources
|
The List:
See Mobile Command Post/Incident Set Up, Search Manager Guideline 17. Action:
|
|
family liaison
(de)briefing
|
|
-
Suggestion #28:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
+ teams deployed quickly
- teams got out quickly when they were tasked.
|
|
|
searching
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
-
Suggestion #38:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
reinterpretation of assignment. when does a clue become a change of assignment? Could you change assigned search type without confirmation from command.
- comes with experience
extrication
|
|
|
access/return from segment
|
-
Suggestion #42:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
never split team returning from field
- training exercise artifact
stand down
|
CISM
prevention, public education
travel
only the RCMP can shut down road, we might request
|
planning
|
|
logistics
|
|
2013-01-15 preplan: MOU with CMR should solve further issues |
|
operations
|
-
Suggestion #51:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
balancing priorities with multiple subjects
- handled appropriate
media
family
|
-
Suggestion #52:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
+ family liaison
post ops
leave it up to search managers to delegate jobs before releasing searchers |
-
Suggestion #53:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
Nobody should leave until everything is packed up to go. Don't leave until released.
- same as before
learning
(e.g., how this critique was organized, mock search goals, exercise techniques)
|
-
Suggestion #54:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
more scenarios
- on the mock
- not more subjects
- command post issue
misc
|
-
Suggestion #55:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
use the best equipment -> index criteria
- not understood
|
-
Suggestion #56:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
get stuff ready sooner, incl. vehicle
- covered earlier
|
|
|
|
-
Suggestion #60:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
+ accountability at hill
|
-
Suggestion #61:
- Committee handling: unassigned
- Value to PCSAR mandate: not rated
- Difficulty to implement: not rated
Had radio reception, but no phone reception. use mountain safety office.
- Knowing in advance where good facilities are at CMR - e.g. command post.
- handled
Committee handling | Suggestion/Committee/List/unassigned +, Suggestion/Committee/List/preplan +, Suggestion/Committee/List/training +, and Suggestion/Committee/List/equipment + |
Description | define level of response +, clarify purpose of task +, on-call person to have call-out list on person - program cell phone +, + delegate to other
|
Difficulty to implement | not rated +, done +, easy +, hard +, and medium + |
Full page name | Critiques/2010-03-21 + |
Person handling | Cindy Mauthe Drake +, and Brett Wuth + |
Review | unspecified + |
Sequence number | 1 +, 2 +, 3 +, 4 +, 5 +, 6 +, 7 +, 8 +, 9 +, 10 +, 11 +, 12 +, 13 +, 14 +, 15 +, 16 +, 17 +, 18 +, 19 +, 20 +, 21 +, 22 +, 23 +, 24 +, 25 +, 26 +, 27 +, 28 +, 29 +, 30 +, 31 +, 32 +, 33 +, 34 +, 35 +, 36 +, 37 +, 38 +, 39 +, 42 +, 43 +, 44 +, 45 +, 46 +, 47 +, 48 +, 49 +, 51 +, 52 +, 53 +, 54 +, 55 +, 56 +, 57 +, 58 +, 59 +, 60 +, and 61 + |
Value to PCSAR mandate | medium +, none +, not rated +, high +, and low + |
Categories: Committee unassigned | Value medium | Difficulty not rated | Value none | Value not rated | Difficulty done | Committee preplan | Person Cindy Mauthe Drake | Value high | Difficulty easy | Review/Brett Wuth | Committee training | Value low | Person Brett Wuth | Committee equipment | Difficulty hard | Difficulty medium